Foros / Sponsoring a Child in India / Education for Girls in India

Education for Girls in India

Thread is closed for posting
25 publicaciones
kramsey
septiembre 21, 2011

I know there is a lot of variety to this, but I was wondering what other people's experiences were--how long do you think I can expect my 8-year-old sponsored girl to stay in school? I am worried about her getting a quality education.

And, is there any way I can specifically help her further her education?

jenkinsg
septiembre 21, 2011

Indian children are required to go to school through 10th grade (or until they reach a certain age--16, I think). Enforcement is spotty. And oftentimes even when parents want to comply, they can't afford required fees, school supplies, and clothing. That's one of the benefits of CI.

All students take annual exams around the beginning of January, which they must pass to be promoted to the next grade. (No "social promotion" like in the U.S.). Primary school grades are K-5; High school starts with 6th grade. Grades 6-10 are "lower secondary" grades. Grades 11 and 12 are optional, essentially college prep.

At the end of 10th grade, they take a big exam that determines whether they can go on to 11th grade. (Yes, it's the same system they use at Hogwarts. Young British wizards take OWLs; Bengali teens take the Madhymuk exam.)

If they continue to "Higher Secondary" school, at the end of grade 12 they take another required exam (HSE) that they must pass to continue on to college. (Like N.E.W.T.s)



Traditionally, Indian girls were married around the time they were 14 or 15. This practice is now illegal (legal marriage ages are now 18 for girls and 21 for men), but again, enforcement is spotty. One of my girls left the program to marry shortly before she turned 16 (she'd completed most of 10th grade); another sponsor has recently lost a 14 year-old.


You can provide money for "private tuitions," (the Indian term for "tutoring") very cheaply, and it's not subject to the minimum for SNG contributions. A year's tutoring for a primary school student runs $25-$70, depending on location and frequency. ($70 is what I pay for an urban child who is several years behind; $25 covers a rural child working on grade level. I assume the latter gets shorter, less frequent sessions while the former is working with a tutor several times a week or daily.)

If your 8 year-old is in 2nd grade or higher, they're probably OK for now. You can ask for an education report, and provide tuitions if it's requested. Or, if you plan to send a $100+ SNG, you can suggest that part of it be used for what I generally call "academic support," to avoid forcing them to get tutoring for a student who's doing fine.

kramsey
septiembre 21, 2011

Thanks so much! That info was really helpful. Just what i was looking for.

ponyiq
septiembre 21, 2011

I am the sponsor that lost a 14 year old to marriage. She was an exceptionally motivated and strong student. She was at or above grade level, she had accepted tuitions so taht she could do even better and with that she was very blessed and did very well on all of her test. She married within days of turning 14 years old. I was very displeased as her family was aware that I wanted her to stay in school well; i did not say it outright but I attempted to make it as known as i could.. but she left.

On the other hand, i ended up paying the tuitions for her brother who is in XI grade.. he as the final exams to prepare for.. in fact.. he bought a copy of the practice test papers and my tutoring for tulasi was used with my permission for her brother.. for $35 he was able to get tuitions in two subjects geography and english, a copy of the practice test papers and one other item.. i was very pleased that at least he was continuing his education but angry that his parents chose to marry off their 14 year old daughter, remove her from school both of which are illegal, so obviously not enforced.

Missing user
septiembre 21, 2011

Jenkinsg did a lot to go through all the practical bits-- she knows more than I on that. I do certainly emphasize though that just because a law is on the books in India, does not in any sense guarantee that the law is being enforced.

An additional issue in India is that a lot of the parents of our CI kids (i.e. daily laborer/worker) did not go to school (or to very much) and many are functionally illiterate. Therefore they cannot help with homework (or may not understand the importance of homework), don't know how to navigate the world of education or how to advocate for their child's education, and may not truly understand where their child can go with an education.

That is why I feel it is VERY important to be a strong advocate of education for your sponsored child in India. Asking how school is going, what grade they are in, when they will take their exams and how they did on them will show the child and family that education is important to you (and hopefully if it is not already, become more important to them too).

Saba, my 12 year old was stuck in 2nd grade for three years. I had her a tutor but she still ended up repeating again. With my inquiries and continued donations for tuitions (tutoring) her parents switched her school (perhaps finally realizing something wasn't working well for her there). So the added interest and help on my part may have helped the parents pay more attention.

I also had a big issue with my 18 year old Khayrunnesha this year. She started school late, but has been doing well. She told me she wanted to go to college and get her Bachelors in Education. She was in 10th grade but failed to pass her 10th grade exams. She decided to quit school. The CI field officers visited her to try to get her to reconsider but she refused. Then I wrote her a letter, in which I told her my fiance Vivek (who also grew up in India) also failed an exam in highschool and had to repeat a year, and he was now a phd student. I told her we all have hard times and she should not give up on her dreams. She she did decide to try again, and will be studying throughout the year and re-taking the exams next spring. She also chose to do a tailoring course as well.

I think telling her about a a successful student in India who had to repeat a grade made her realize it is not that uncommon (It is not-- the tests can be very difficult and the quality of teachers quite varied). In India people would be embarassed about such a failure, and probably wouldn't go around telling everyone about it. But KNOWING that may have changed her idea of what it is like to be a student. (I think many lower class families in India also see education as an investment, and if a child isn't doing really well, then perhaps not worth the investment-- so they also need to be shown that some failures do not mean they should give up entirely on educating that child).

So I definately think that asking the child details about school and study will send a message that you value education. Also, offering to pay for tuitions, even for a child doing well on grade level, will give them an extra boost. (Most midle and upper class children in India have tuitions after or before school, even if they are doing well-- often times children cannot learn everything they need to pass the exams in class-- but that's a different post!)

kramsey
septiembre 22, 2011

Thanks again for the useful info. Ponyiq, I can only imagine the heartbreak you must have felt at losing your sponsored child to marriage so early. This is exactly the thing I want to try to avoid--but if that's what the parents want, what can you do? I will do my best to send signals that I am concerned about Mina's education and hope that the parents feel the same way.

Missing user
octubre 5, 2011

Every letter to my little one in India touches on the importance of education. though I try not to be overwelming.

chanachi
octubre 7, 2014
This is all good info.  I just wish I knew it sooner. 
Missing user
agosto 13, 2016
My parents just sponsored an 8 year old girl in Kolkata who is not going to school. The reason listed is "family lacks money". She also has two sisters ages 11 and 6, I don't know if either of them are in school. I worry about these girls' future if they don't get an education! Any suggestions for how to help get them enrolled in school?
Missing user
agosto 13, 2016 en respuesta a Missing user
Ask CI for an educational report on the children and how much it would cost for them to go to school.  If you inquire about this the family will be under the impression that you go forward with the funding though.
wallyflores
agosto 13, 2016 en respuesta a Missing user
Agree with Bill. My teen Farheen from Kolkata used an EG I sent for her 10th grade fees and I believe she had a little money left over too ($100).  So it may not be too expensive.  Worth inquiring with CI
Missing user
agosto 13, 2016 en respuesta a wallyflores
Education in India in a government school is free through 10th grade (standard) which is the last year/level required (Right to Education Act, 2009). However most Indian children benefit from tutoring which is an expense for the parents. It is a very small cost for sponsors and the amount needed depends on whether the tutoring is private in-home or group. Parents pay for school supplies but not books through grade 10.
debbies
agosto 15, 2016 en respuesta a Missing user
Chat,e-mail or call our Care Team and we can send a memo to find out more about the situation, what she needs for school and the cost. Thanks!
grandpaNicky
agosto 15, 2016
Sorry to get off subject in India, but I was in a wallyworld the other day and looked at displayed list of items needed by classes from preschool to high school. The very first item for every single grade was ear buds. WHY !!!
Missing user
agosto 15, 2016 en respuesta a grandpaNicky
I know here in Maryland, our school system is turning towards technology based learning. Soon all kids will have there own laptop that is used in school as opposed to books. 
tarideyoe
febrero 7, 2018 en respuesta a kramsey

I  had a little girl from India from age 8-18. She finished her primary and secondary school and planned to further her education.  She wants to be a doctor and come back to help her people. I was delighted at how well she did and am very proud of her & CI sponsored her until she turned 18. I have not heard from her since she finished the program but I’m sure CI started her in the right direction. 

DorisR
octubre 28, 2018 en respuesta a jenkinsg
The cost for private tutoring was much higher for me. I had requested to know a years worth tutoring for my sponsor child and her older sibling and the cost varies by grade. I ended up paying $109.00 for the lower grade and $127.00 for the higher grade for the year. I expect that cost to be higher next year. I am saying this because someone mentioned $70.00 and $25.00. It depends on the grade and how often the child gets tutoring.
Missing user
octubre 28, 2018 en respuesta a DorisR
Costs for tutoring (tuitions) are extremely variable and have been for a long time. Costs for group tutoring are less expensive than for private in-home tutoring. Grades below 9 are generally less expensive. For classes 9 through 12 costs increase considerably. For these grades tutoring is given by subject. The child may require tutoring for one or several subjects. Costs are also different ​for Delhi, for Kolkata and for rural W. Bengal. I've found I need to request an estimate yearly once the children have entered 9th grade. (This year two Delhi children required $274 each for class 10 in preparation for their board exams. One rural W. Bengal child will require $184 for class 11.)
Missing user
noviembre 1, 2018 en respuesta a Missing user
Yes ,I check every year and every year it's a bit more .Don't get me wrong, I don't mind, because every year I'm paying is another year my girls remain in school! 
Missing user
diciembre 21, 2018
Is there any way to help get a child back into school? My sponsor child is 15, and is currently not attending school. The reason is listed as "Other." I'd love it if she could go back to school, even if just for another year. I'd help pay for her to get tutoring or whatever is limiting her from continuing school. How can I do this?
Missing user
diciembre 21, 2018 en respuesta a Missing user
You can ask CI to visit and interview your child and her family and report to you on her education situation and needs. It’ll take a couple of months. The family might not have money to send her to school or it might not be a priority for them. Many Indian girls quit school young to marry or help their families at home. CI can help you find out more. School in Delhi starts in April, so you have time.
Missing user
diciembre 21, 2018 en respuesta a Missing user
Contact CI and request an educational inquiry.  It'll take about 6 weeks to get back to you, but it will help you understand what her situation is and how best to help her.  After you know that information, you can work with CI to set up whatever is needed to get her back in school if that is what she desires.
Missing user
diciembre 21, 2018 en respuesta a Missing user
It seems to me that because Gulafsa is age 15 the first step for you is to find the reason she is not in school. This will help you know if a return to school is possible and in what ways you might help her.
Missing user
diciembre 21, 2018 en respuesta a Missing user
Thank you Nancy! I will definitely do that. I will ask her in my next letter.
Missing user
enero 4, 2019 en respuesta a Missing user
I second what everyone else said, but will add that students have to take an exam in India to attend 11-12 grades.  At 15, she's about the right age that she may not have passed the exam.  Always good to ask though :-)
Close